RegisterLog in
Main forum

Post Your Lineage

6 year(s) ago • 59850 views • 355 replies

Darius Kumana
Darius Kumana
Black beltVerified16 forum posts2485/1000
4 year(s) ago
Although there is little doubt that BJJ has become one of the most effective combat arts in the world, there is often confusion as to where these grappling arts originated and what constitutes “real” BJJ...

Questions like - “When/how exactly did Jiu-Jitsu / Judo move from Japan to Brazil and become Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu? or “How does Gracie Jiu-jitsu (made famous through Helio Gracie and his family) fit in with your history?”

Whilst interesting academic questions for historians - these questions can sometimes be unhelpful as they can cause unnecessary rifts between proponents of the art.

At The Fighting Arts Academy - we are keen to promote authentic Brazilian JiuJitsu and grappling - regardless of its origins. The beautiful thing about our sport is that it is regularly battle-tested so there is little doubt of the style’s efficacy. We are also keen to encourage evolution within the sport so are keen to teach evolving techniques such as leg-locks (which are often frowned upon by traditionalists) to our advanced students.

For the historians amongst you, the following link provides a write up of where my jiujitsu comes from.

https://www.thefightingar[...]g-heritage
Mariano
Mariano
Black beltVerified29 forum posts1765/1000
4 year(s) ago
Had not thought about it:

a. Mitsuyo Maeda > Carlos Gracie > Helio Gracie > Flavio Behring > Manuel Rey > me

b. Mitsuyo Maeda > Carlos Gracie > Carlson Gracie > Ze Mario Sperry > me

Both are obviously incredible masters and the styles are completely different.

Under Flavio Behring my experience was a more self defense approach to bjj even in the promotions they wanted to see the "self defense techniques" also lots of emphasis on being more subtle or more technical I guess.

Under Mario Sperry the game is full on top pressure, never on the bottom only to sweep, we don't pull guard, etc. lol. A lot of wrestling and deep half guard in the game.
A lot has to do with the history of your lineage. If your teacher is an mma or ex professional fighter usually their style is going to be a lot rougher than your "normal black belt" at least that has been my experience.
Of course at the end of the day it is really up to you, the type of game or techniques that you want to use.

I think I have been lucky to be able to train under both styles. Just my two cents.
Jon Waddle
Jon Waddle
Black belt 1st degreeVerified81 forum posts2070/1000
4 year(s) ago
First half of my journey was as follows: Maeda->Carlos Gracie->Helio Gracie->Pedro Sauer->Allen Hopkins->Sean Sharp->Me

My current lineage is:Maeda->Carlos Gracie->Carlson Gracie Sr.->Ricardo Cavalcanti->Me
Nick Tyau
Nick Tyau
Black belt 1st degreeVerified314 forum posts4290/1000
4 year(s) ago
Helio Gracie - Carlos Gracie, Sr. - Carlos Gracie Jr. - Ailson “Jucão” Henrique Brites - Walter Johnson - Me
I train under Jucao too. Hope to run into you at a seminar soon
Olivier Hennau
Olivier Hennau
Black belt 1st degreeVerified219 forum posts7200/1000
4 year(s) ago
i did this, only for the fun to do it when i was injured and had time to loose,

i found a tree on the net and completed it
Mikey Page
Mikey Page
Purple beltVerified108 forum posts2520/400
4 year(s) ago
So this is new to me and very interesting from a history standpoint. As I end up in a Wikipedia vortex when researching places to visit, military history etc. So naturally i am inclined to see what this lineage thing is about. So here's mine

Kano Jigoro > Mitsuyo Maeda > Carlos Gracie Sr > Carlos Gracie Jr > Rigan Machado > Chris Hauter > Matt Thornton > Prit Mikhelson > Chris Paines > Roger Karel > Me

Very interesting to see as it actually got me seeing how this sport developed to what it is today. But doesn't really bother me as i just enjoy learning stuff and meeting people.
Darius Kumana
Darius Kumana
Black beltVerified16 forum posts2485/1000
4 year(s) ago
This is a fuller tree I have been working on...
I know lineage is not necessarily a reflection of a practitioners skill, but I have found through this research exercise that I have made friends in academies in different parts of the world and as a consequence my Jiujitsu family is getting bigger.
Bobby McMasters
Bobby McMasters
Black belt 1st degreeVerified1276 forum posts13440/1000
4 year(s) ago
i did this, only for the fun to do it when i was injured and had time to loose, i found a tree on the net and completed it
I really like this diagram, dude. What I can see of it anyway (picture quality isn't too sharp on my phone).

But you forgot to include the world's latest affiliation, the BJJ Globetrotters. Where do they fit in on the lineage/affiliation family tree?
Efi Luis
Efi Luis
Black belt 1st degreeVerified4 forum posts3360/1000
4 year(s) ago
Lineage: Mitsuyo Maeda > Carlos Gracie Sr. > Carlos Gracie Junior > Vinicius Magalhães “Draculino” > Remco Pardoel > Anes Abazovic > Me
Edward Rinda
Edward Rinda
Black belt 3rd degreeVerified7 forum posts2070/1000
4 year(s) ago
Mitsuyo Maeda > Carlos Gracie > Carlson Gracie > Ricardo Libório > Emyr Bussade/Marcel Ferreira > Edward Rinda
Chris Thompson
Chris Thompson
Black belt 2nd degreeVerified28 forum posts5740/1000
4 year(s) ago
I always felt the whole lineage praising culture was kind of weird. If I take my own students, some of them are super talented and medal at big tournaments. Some of them are blue belts for 10 years and lose first match in every single competition. Some of them copy my game to the detail, some go their own way and develop completely distinct style. I dont see why they should get anything out of saying I’m their lineage, when so many other factors play in. An important point to consider of course, is that this is kind of unique to jiu jitsu. Why don’t golfers, tennis players, table tennis players, cyclists and marathon runner talk about their lineage like jiu jitsu people do? It’s weird. Just weird.
Spot on... nothing else needs ri be said. Its one thing to be proud of your team and skills, but thinking you are better than someone else due to lineage is weird af
Mirco
Mirco
Brown beltVerified832 forum posts6445/700
4 year(s) ago
i did this, only for the fun to do it when i was injured and had time to loose, i found a tree on the net and completed it
Hy Oliver, I can’t read the name under the picture of the guy next to Carlos Senior, but I suppose, as there is „Fadda“ in the next branch, the name is Franca? …. Well the guy on the picture is Jose Sebador Rosa from Minas Gerais and not Franca.
He has nothing to do with Fadda lineage!
Olivier Hennau
Olivier Hennau
Black belt 1st degreeVerified219 forum posts7200/1000
4 year(s) ago
Hy Oliver, I can’t read the name under the picture of the guy next to Carlos Senior, but I suppose, as there is „Fadda“ in the next branch, the name is Franca? …. Well the guy on the picture is Jose Sebador Rosa from Minas Gerais and not Franca. He has nothing to do with Fadda lineage!
Well, ... as i wrote : i found this on the net and completed "my part" (so the last 3 lines) ;-) i'm not the author !

here is the link, that you can complain to the right interlocutor :-D
https://comunicajiujitsu.[...]rasileiro/


the name is Luis França, correct

about the pics, i do not met Master França personnaly, so i can't say if the picture is him or not :-D , sorry
the only thing i can say is that bjj-fanatics use the same pic as you can see here
https://bjjfanatics.com.b[...]brasileiro

see a focus of the part :
Edited 4 year(s) ago
Mirco
Mirco
Brown beltVerified832 forum posts6445/700
4 year(s) ago
the focus
Hy Oliver, thanks.
They are wrong, too, I think.
There was the same pic with the name of Mestre Jose Senador Rosa under it on a Brasilian Homepage of the Federacao mineira de Jiu Jitsu (couldn’t find it anymore/ maybe it is down), who founded this federation in 1975 together with Mestre Adair Alves de Almeida, mestre Adilson Ferreira and Takeo Yano (one of the first judokas coming to brasil after Maeda).
I found a pic of the former homepage on „livrozillo“:
Mirco
Mirco
Brown beltVerified832 forum posts6445/700
4 year(s) ago
Well, ... as i wrote : i found this on the net and completed 'my part' (so the last 3 lines) ;-) i'm not the author ! here is the link, that you can complain to the right interlocutor :-D https://comunicajiujitsu.[...]rasileiro/ the name is Luis França, correct about the pics, i do not met Master França personnaly, so i can't say if the picture is him or not :-D , sorry the only thing i can say is that bjj-fanatics use the same pic as you can see here https://bjjfanatics.com.b[...]brasileiro see a focus of the part :
Here is a pic of him with Takeo Yano, when Jose Senador Rosa was younger.
It is from student of Jose Senador Rosa and Takeo Yano, Mestre Jose Adilson Ferreira:
http://www.equipegaviaoji[...]su.com.br/

Mirco
Mirco
Brown beltVerified832 forum posts6445/700
4 year(s) ago
Well, ... as i wrote : i found this on the net and completed 'my part' (so the last 3 lines) ;-) i'm not the author ! here is the link, that you can complain to the right interlocutor :-D https://comunicajiujitsu.[...]rasileiro/ the name is Luis França, correct about the pics, i do not met Master França personnaly, so i can't say if the picture is him or not :-D , sorry the only thing i can say is that bjj-fanatics use the same pic as you can see here https://bjjfanatics.com.b[...]brasileiro see a focus of the part :
As I am very interested in history, origins and lineages of bjj I did lots of research (read all the „Choque“ books, etc.) and contacted „old“ BJJ teachers from Takeo Yano lineage, etc… at the source in Brazil who were either students of Jose Senador Rosa and/ or knew him and Takeo Yano personally.
This is part of an email I once got from one of the co founders of the Federacao mineira de Jiu Jitsu in Minas Gerais/ Brasil, Mestre Adair Alves De Almeida (who knew Takeo Yano and Jose Senador Rosa and was , I think, back then in the mid 70s, a student of one of them). He send me pictures of Jose Senador Rosa and Yano for example, too. So as I understood Mestre Jose Senador Rosa was a Training partner and close friend of mestre Takeo Yano , but he had diplomas from the famous „Ono“ Brothers from São Paolo and from Helio Gracie! Nothing to do with Fadda Lineage:
„
Jon
Jon
Purple beltVerified89 forum posts1345/400
4 year(s) ago
I'm mostly Danish, but there's a nasty rumour that my great grandfather was a German.
Bobby McMasters
Bobby McMasters
Black belt 1st degreeVerified1276 forum posts13440/1000
4 year(s) ago
As I am very interested in history, origins and lineages of bjj I did lots of research (read all the „Choque“ books, etc.) and contacted „old“ BJJ teachers from Takeo Yano lineage, etc… at the source in Brazil who were either students of Jose Senador Rosa and/ or knew him and Takeo Yano personally.
Have you read "Opening Closed Guard" by Robert Drysdale yet? It might answer a lot of the questions you have already, and probably save you some of the legwork you're already doing. Maybe?

I think he did a fairly solid job of calling into question some of the accepted Oswaldo Fadda "myths" as well. I found the book to be super interesting, and would highly recommend it to anybody who has spent years listening and adhering to the standard Gracie narrative of BJJ history.
Olivier Hennau
Olivier Hennau
Black belt 1st degreeVerified219 forum posts7200/1000
4 year(s) ago
As I am very interested in history, origins and lineages of bjj I did lots of research (read all the „Choque“ books, etc.) and contacted „old“ BJJ teachers from Takeo Yano lineage, etc… at the source in Brazil who were either students of Jose Senador Rosa and/ or knew him and Takeo Yano personally. This is part of an email I once got from one of the co founders of the Federacao mineira de Jiu Jitsu in Minas Gerais/ Brasil, Mestre Adair Alves De Almeida (who knew Takeo Yano and Jose Senador Rosa and was , I think, back then in the mid 70s, a student of one of them). He send me pictures of Jose Senador Rosa and Yano for example, too. So as I understood Mestre Jose Senador Rosa was a Training partner and close friend of mestre Takeo Yano , but he had diplomas from the famous „Ono“ Brothers from São Paolo and from Helio Gracie! Nothing to do with Fadda Lineage: „
i did not want you to explain, as i did this only for fun and again i'm not the author ... my interrest in lineage is very limited

but i truly like that some history "nerds" try to debunk some myth, so it's cool

thx for sharing anyway
Mirco
Mirco
Brown beltVerified832 forum posts6445/700
4 year(s) ago
Have you read 'Opening Closed Guard' by Robert Drysdale yet? It might answer a lot of the questions you have already, and probably save you some of the legwork you're already doing. Maybe? I think he did a fairly solid job of calling into question some of the accepted Oswaldo Fadda 'myths' as well. I found the book to be super interesting, and would highly recommend it to anybody who has spent years listening and adhering to the standard Gracie narrative of BJJ history.
Hey Robert, of course I read it ;-)
Still waiting for the „movie“ though….

Danny Boy Vega
Danny Boy Vega
Black belt 1st degreeVerified27 forum posts3005/1000
4 year(s) ago
Mitsuyo Madea > Carlos Gracie > Helio Gracie > Rolls Gracie > Romero Jacare Cavalcanti > Felipe "Zicro" Neto > me ("Danny Boy"Vega)

I'm in one of the framed pictures under the lineage wall sticker alongside other black belts promoted under Zicro
Edited 4 year(s) ago
Sebastien Cote
Sebastien Cote
Black belt 1st degreeVerified9 forum posts1820/1000
4 year(s) ago
Here's mine :)

Renzo Gracie, then Kevin Taylor and Peter Martell from Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada, then my instructor Nathan Stever from Bathurst, New-Brunswick and then me out of Riviere-du-Loup, Quebec, Canada
I feel very privileged to have this picture with pretty much all my lineage !
This picture was taken during a seminar on may 18,2019 in Halifax, Nova Scotia. Renzo took time to take a photo with every participant and we were close to 200 peoples. What a boss and a truly gentleman icon.

Post a reply

Add a quote
 
Changes saved
Success
An error occured
Required fields missing
This person is already on Beltchecker.