RegisterLog in
Main forum

IBJJF RULES DICTATING BLACK BELT PROMOTIONS

7 month(s) ago • 1289 views • 32 replies

William Murphy
William Murphy
Black belt 5th degreeVerified2144 forum posts26155/1000
6 month(s) ago
Social affirmation, IMO, is not the same thing as a promotion. I don't have to like you to think you could or should be in charge.
I agree with the second entirely, and the first partially.
Isaac
Isaac
Black beltVerified265 forum posts5755/1000
24 minute(s) ago
I was listening to a Carlson Gracie Jr. interview and he talked about stripes. I thought it was relevant to this old conversation. Its at 4:20 in the video.

"Many people back in the days, you know, we didn't have no degrees on the belts. So my first time I put a degree on my belt I was I already going to my fourth degree and I ask my father "my student start asking me what degree I am", my dad say "doesn't matter you're my black belt that's the most important". And I say "but they want to know" he say "put whatever you want" and then they start with the system of the years and things. So first time I put it was a third degree. Was a time where so many people are getting promote to black belt and people didn't know where they come from, because back in the days it was not the rules that you must reach some level as a black belt to be able to promote somebody. Nowadays we have to be third degree black belt to promote somebody to black belt. Back in the days you get a black belt, you look to the side and your friend is brown, you say "okay you are black belt too". So many people are getting like that some people for far away from the source, allegedly paying to get black belt."

https://www.youtube.com/w[...]J5nrRGd0fg
Philip Dunlap
Philip Dunlap
Black belt 3rd degreeVerified1047 forum posts61210/1000
10 minute(s) ago
Let's face it there is no general consensus on what a Black belt is. Hell ask 10 different Martial artists what constitutes a martial art and you will probably get 10 different answers,, Listen I bust on Johan more than most buy he is consistent in his criteria and what I like about this site is when seeing peoples votes you get a real community consensus on someones reputation among there peers

Post a reply

Add a quote
 
Changes saved
Success
An error occured
Required fields missing
This person is already on Beltchecker.