RegisterLog in
Main forum

Master's against the rules

4 year(s) ago • 2153 views • 54 replies

Benoit Zenthner
Benoit Zenthner
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago

Hi,

I was just look at the post on "master Lasu" who claims a 7 th degree Coral belt. In the post People talk about on of his student we got promoted strait from Brown belt to 2nd degree Black belt. Everybody says that it's not normal or legit... in this case, the "Master" is obviously fake, but would it seen as legit if he was a true Master ?
In martial arts in general, Master are allowed to do what they want sometimes.

I remember, that when GM Flavio Behring came In France In the very first time at the end of 90's, the highest rank where blue belt, and he decided to promote tree People from blue to Black belt the same Day, "to help jiujitsu growing faster". As a 8th degree Red belt, no one can really go against his will.

It's not the same case but when you see guys promoted to Black belt In really short among of time, like 18 month for Travis Stevens, Masters sometimes didn't respect the rules.

But is this consider as legit, when the decision come from that kind of autority ?
Christian Graugart
Christian Graugart
Black belt 4th degreeVerified4323 forum posts39315/1000
4 year(s) ago
I remember, that when GM Flavio Behring came In France In the very first time at the end of 90's, the highest rank where blue belt, and he decided to promote tree People from blue to Black belt the same Day, "to help jiujitsu growing faster". As a 8th degree Red belt, no one can really go against his will.
There was actually a Danish guy who lived in france and trained under Flavio back then. He came to Denmark to teach the first ever BJJ seminar and was wearing a black belt with a blue bar. He had some story about how instructor blue belts got to wear a black belt. It was kind of a weird logic and nobody was really buying it :D but might have been connected to your story there
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
There was actually a Danish guy who lived in france and trained under Flavio back then. He came to Denmark to teach the first ever BJJ seminar and was wearing a black belt with a blue bar. He had some story about how instructor blue belts got to wear a black belt. It was kind of a weird logic and nobody was really buying it :D but might have been connected to your story there
Yes at first they had that kind of belt, those guys : Christian Derval, Patrick Bittan and Alain Nagera comes from the Cercle Tissier, the first BJJ academy in Europe, who organise the very first Seminar with Rickson Gracie in 1995. That gym was kind of the meca for a lot of french community praticioners, in early 2000 they had around 300 students and People who comes from all the country to train and refine the game. That academy is in Paris. On the same time, in South of France and Italy, David Giorsetti was one of the pionniers, as the Fernandez brothers Emmanuel and Frederic in South West.
Manu Fernandez was my first teacher back then and we organise also in 2003 the very first Seminar with Laurence Cousin, Brown belt at that time, who becomes few years later the first non brazilian female world champion in adult Black belt IBJJF.
Memories.... i gonna try to find, i still have all of the magazines from that era, with blue belt teaching techniques and doing instructionals VHS, we where waiting to learn new techniques so much, it was pretty rare back then. And i still have pictures somewhere with those weird Black and blue belt, i gonna search and add it to the post when i found it.
Christian Graugart
Christian Graugart
Black belt 4th degreeVerified4323 forum posts39315/1000
4 year(s) ago
Haha that's so funny, it's the first time I've heard it referenced since that seminar back then. Was maybe around 2001-2002
Slideyfoot [jun]
Slideyfoot [jun]
Black belt 1st degreeVerified1900 forum posts3635/1000
4 year(s) ago
Yes at first they had that kind of belt, those guys : Christian Derval, Patrick Bittan and Alain Nagera comes from the Cercle Tissier, the first BJJ academy in Europe, who organise the very first Seminar with Rickson Gracie in 1995. That gym was kind of the meca for a lot of french community praticioners, in early 2000 they had around 300 students and People who comes from all the country to train and refine the game. That academy is in Paris. On the same time, in South of France and Italy, David Giorsetti was one of the pionniers, as the Fernandez brothers Emmanuel and Frederic in South West. Manu Fernandez was my first teacher back then and we organise also in 2003 the very first Seminar with Laurence Cousin, Brown belt at that time, who becomes few years later the first non brazilian female world champion in adult Black belt IBJJF. Memories.... i gonna try to find, i still have all of the magazines from that era, with blue belt teaching techniques and doing instructionals VHS, we where waiting to learn new techniques so much, it was pretty rare back then. And i still have pictures somewhere with those weird Black and blue belt, i gonna search and add it to the post when i found it.
Cool, thanks for the history lesson, Benoit! :D
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
If you guys came in France, take one of two days to visit us in Belgium, it's not so far and we had pretty good arguments like Belgian Beer, Belgian Chocolate and Belgian fries ;-)

Everyone should have a belgian friend XD
Edited 4 year(s) ago
Slideyfoot [jun]
Slideyfoot [jun]
Black belt 1st degreeVerified1900 forum posts3635/1000
4 year(s) ago
Belgium is awesome: I was born in Brussels, but haven't spent as much time there as I'd like. Though I will be back for the leglock camp in Leuven next month. I don't like leglocks, so it's an "eat your vegetables" situation, but I will enjoy checking out all the great art again. :D
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
Belgium is awesome: I was born in Brussels, but haven't spent as much time there as I'd like. Though I will be back for the leglock camp in Leuven next month. I don't like leglocks, so it's an 'eat your vegetables' situation, but I will enjoy checking out all the great art again. :D
When you come for your fetish seminar, if you've enough to smell feet all Day long you can visit us to do something else ;-)
It's one of the BJJ fundamentals, always find an escape :)

Much seriously enjoy your camp and you're welcome if you want to

James Jones
James Jones
Black beltVerified1310 forum posts6475/1000
4 year(s) ago
If you guys came in France, take one of two days to visit us in Belgium, it's not so far and we had pretty good arguments like Belgian Beer, Belgian Chocolate and Belgian fries ;-) Everyone should have a belgian friend XD
All I remember in Belgium was some pissing statue. I was only there for like 2 hours though.
Edited 4 year(s) ago
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
All I remember in Belgium was some pissing statue. I was only there for like 2 hours though.
You probably mean "Manneken pis"
Pretty smal but cool and famous, the legend says that a kid from Brussels stop fire by pissing and save the city...that's where it come's from.
It's close from the "Grand-Place", also something to visit if you like old monuments.
Edited 4 year(s) ago
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
Okay i just think about the fact that we start talking about everything except the post subject ahahaha.

So, deep breath, concentration....

Did you think that a master should be over the rules if he decide to go his own way, jumping belt from blue or purple strait to Black or giving degrees too fast.
I know that IBJJF will never approve that but what's your feeling people ?

I think that every school should do as they want if they are active in exanges like comptetitions, seminars, openmat,... so people can proof what they are made off and then becoming legit or fraud... at the end of the Day, that's the school or Master credibility who's engage.
I also had student very talented and it was more challenging for them to fight in higher belt divisions than loosing motivation witout any challenge
Deepu
Deepu
Black beltVerified547 forum posts6410/1000
4 year(s) ago
Yes at first they had that kind of belt, those guys : Christian Derval, Patrick Bittan and Alain Nagera comes from the Cercle Tissier, the first BJJ academy in Europe, who organise the very first Seminar with Rickson Gracie in 1995. That gym was kind of the meca for a lot of french community praticioners, in early 2000 they had around 300 students and People who comes from all the country to train and refine the game. That academy is in Paris. On the same time, in South of France and Italy, David Giorsetti was one of the pionniers, as the Fernandez brothers Emmanuel and Frederic in South West. Manu Fernandez was my first teacher back then and we organise also in 2003 the very first Seminar with Laurence Cousin, Brown belt at that time, who becomes few years later the first non brazilian female world champion in adult Black belt IBJJF. Memories.... i gonna try to find, i still have all of the magazines from that era, with blue belt teaching techniques and doing instructionals VHS, we where waiting to learn new techniques so much, it was pretty rare back then. And i still have pictures somewhere with those weird Black and blue belt, i gonna search and add it to the post when i found it.
Cecle Tissier as in Cristian Tissier's school? Wow, he came to Montreal for several Aikido seminars that I attended back in my Aikido past life. So his academy invited Rickson? Had no idea that he influenced bjj in France.
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
Cecle Tissier as in Cristian Tissier's school? Wow, he came to Montreal for several Aikido seminars that I attended back in my Aikido past life. So his academy invited Rickson? Had no idea that he influenced bjj in France.
Actually the guy who invite Rickson was Christian Derval, a judo teacher at Cercle Tissier and close friend of Christian Tissier.
He propose it and Christian Tissier says that it was a good idea and give his support to make it happen.
I'm still in aïkido,with a fifth dan Black belt and can say that Christian Tissier is pretty amazing at it.
Drew Brunning
Drew Brunning
Black beltVerified235 forum posts3190/1000
4 year(s) ago
BJJ lacks a belt validation process the way judo has because BJJ lacks a centralized rank authority and the use of the board to certify promotions. If you come in with other experience or if you trained for a long time without rank recognition the expectation is generally that you just spend a shorter amount of time in each rank rather than skipping ranks wholesale. You do get situations where like Josh Barnett was promoted from white to black just to be able to compete in a black belt division (https://jiujitsutimes.com[...]you-think/). I think those are weird and it's kind of on the community to decide if it wants to accept them (given that there's no centralized governing body to accept or reject each case).

With respect to black belt degrees - BJJ typically doesn't use them to indicate a level of skill or service to the sport. BJJ, in general, uses them solely for number of years as a black belt. There are exceptions - John Gorman is a coral belt per the IBJJF, but he hasn't been a black belt as long as Chris Haueter (who's not yet a coral belt by time-in-grade). That case largely seems to be because of John Gorman's role in the IBJJF so it's an almost ceremonial promotion (more akin to getting promoted in judo for being on a board helping to run some level of governing body).

So I'd personally say - any colored belt promotion not given by a black belt (or at least signed off on by a black belt), I don't personally agree with and any promotion that skips degrees of black belt regardless of the rank of the person awarding it I don't personally agree with. It'll be on the community to decide at scale though. Seems like the person could just be a black belt and wait the six years to be a 2 stripe.
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
BJJ lacks a belt validation process the way judo has because BJJ lacks a centralized rank authority and the use of the board to certify promotions. If you come in with other experience or if you trained for a long time without rank recognition the expectation is generally that you just spend a shorter amount of time in each rank rather than skipping ranks wholesale. You do get situations where like Josh Barnett was promoted from white to black just to be able to compete in a black belt division (https://jiujitsutimes.com[...]you-think/). I think those are weird and it's kind of on the community to decide if it wants to accept them (given that there's no centralized governing body to accept or reject each case). With respect to black belt degrees - BJJ typically doesn't use them to indicate a level of skill or service to the sport. BJJ, in general, uses them solely for number of years as a black belt. There are exceptions - John Gorman is a coral belt per the IBJJF, but he hasn't been a black belt as long as Chris Haueter (who's not yet a coral belt by time-in-grade). That case largely seems to be because of John Gorman's role in the IBJJF so it's an almost ceremonial promotion (more akin to getting promoted in judo for being on a board helping to run some level of governing body). So I'd personally say - any colored belt promotion not given by a black belt (or at least signed off on by a black belt), I don't personally agree with and any promotion that skips degrees of black belt regardless of the rank of the person awarding it I don't personally agree with. It'll be on the community to decide at scale though. Seems like the person could just be a black belt and wait the six years to be a 2 stripe.
I agree with you, and i think also that in this crazy world where everything is available fast, people loose perseverance. I remember how mad i was when guys who train one's or twice a week, never compet, never train outside our gym, out of shape comes to me after one of two years asking for the next belt....this is the customer way of thinking...in the taekwondo class after us, we see people getting black belt in tree years or less.....if the goal is just to wear a black belt it's faster to buy it on internet ;-) i'm more on old school bushido style, you have to fucking deserved it before getting promoted. But now it's harder to find young people who want to train to enter in the Kumite
Vince Choo
Vince Choo
Black belt 3rd degreeVerified1126 forum posts21045/1000
4 year(s) ago
Seriously though one of my purple belts (Ben) is from Brussels and I agree that you guys have some of best fried potatoes in the world. Maybe it has something to do with the water? or chocolate?
Vince Choo
Vince Choo
Black belt 3rd degreeVerified1126 forum posts21045/1000
4 year(s) ago
Back on topic...

By the time you receive a 4th Degree ~ Coral belt, you can pretty much do whatever you please I think
James Jones
James Jones
Black beltVerified1310 forum posts6475/1000
4 year(s) ago
Seriously though one of my purple belts (Ben) is from Brussels and I agree that you guys have some of best fried potatoes in the world. Maybe it has something to do with the water? or chocolate?
oh yea i also ate some fries and chocolate in the 2 hours I was there lol weird combo
Bobby McMasters
Bobby McMasters
Black belt 1st degreeVerified1272 forum posts12800/1000
4 year(s) ago
By the time you receive a 4th Degree ~ Coral belt, you can pretty much do whatever you please I think
Coral belts are 7th degree black belts, from what I understand.

I don't agree with the logic regarding their ability to do whatever they want though; not a good precedent to set. Drew's assessment was spot-on in my opinion.
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
Seriously though one of my purple belts (Ben) is from Brussels and I agree that you guys have some of best fried potatoes in the world. Maybe it has something to do with the water? or chocolate?
The secret is to choose the good patatoes variety, usualy the "bintje". Then you cut them to the little sticks form. To Cook them you have to do it twice first 3 or 4 minutes at 140°C then around 170/180°C for 3 minutes. And the key to make the difference, it should be fried in "beef white fat". After that put them outside an add a little touch of salt and you can eat them.
You also have to choose your sauce, to put on, we have like 40 or 50 different types, the classicisme like ketchup or mayonaise, than the more belgian originals like: andalouse, samouraï, brazil, américaine,mammouth, hannibal,.....
It's like the gi adduction, very technical xith different brand and taste, you have to find your own way.

If you didn't notice i'm a HUGE fan of belgian fries
Edited 4 year(s) ago
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
Coral belts are 7th degree black belts, from what I understand. I don't agree with the logic regarding their ability to do whatever they want though; not a good precedent to set. Drew's assessment was spot-on in my opinion.
Master Lasu can do whatever he want, he's part of the bjj jedi council.
Vince Choo
Vince Choo
Black belt 3rd degreeVerified1126 forum posts21045/1000
4 year(s) ago
Coral belts are 7th degree black belts, from what I understand. I don't agree with the logic regarding their ability to do whatever they want though; not a good precedent to set. Drew's assessment was spot-on in my opinion.
This is true; however, my personal preference, likes or dislikes will have zero influence on what a more experienced, knowledgeable and skilled teacher with his/her own students and organization, has to do to improve the benefits of the supporters. This is what I meant by they can do as they like. If they were a member of a world organization or unifying body and had to follow those rules, then it would be expected they adopt most of those regulations.

For Beltchecker, as an example, one day, some of you/us will live long enough to be the Coral belt, and it will still be unregulated and loosely or not governed by anyone except our own take on what is best for us/our students. Who would have the right to dictate how you should behave or act if you were in the ballpark sphere of accepted practice? I guess what was considered 'normal' back in the early days of BJJ will no longer be acceptable in the coming decades as trends and population size grows...
Coach
Coach
Black belt 3rd degreeVerified41 forum posts3260/1000
4 year(s) ago
When I was a blue belt, and got my first stripe on my belt at a seminar. My instructor at that time promoted 8 black belts. Was something big at that time. But what I remember what was really suprising was there was a blue belt who left as a brown belt. He tapped out many of the purples and was hanging with the browns pretty aggressively.
From what I could gather from the story he was a black belt from Brazil who wanted to be ranked under my instructor and decided to demote himself to blue belt and start all over.
At one level it was cool but at another he could have blocked others from getting their proper placement.
Brad Neumyer
Brad Neumyer
Purple beltVerified128 forum posts1515/400
4 year(s) ago
...but would it seen as legit if he was a true Master ? In martial arts in general, Master are allowed to do what they want sometimes. I remember, that when GM Flavio Behring came In France In the very first time at the end of 90's, the highest rank where blue belt, and he decided to promote tree People from blue to Black belt the same Day, 'to help jiujitsu growing faster'. As a 8th degree Red belt, no one can really go against his will. It's not the same case but when you see guys promoted to Black belt In really short among of time, like 18 month for Travis Stevens, Masters sometimes didn't respect the rules. But is this consider as legit, when the decision come from that kind of autority ?
This is very interesting, and while it is before my time, I almost sort of understand it. Looking back at the example of Caio Terra/Bruno Malfacine:

"His promotion “landed” on the same year in which the IBJJF set minimum time frames for each belt, making it mandatory for a brown belt to stay in this belt division for a minimum of 1 year before being promoted. As Caio had not hit the time frame outlined by the federation, he was blocked from competing at the 2007 Brazilian Nationals (Brasileiro). Later that year, and although the federation had plans to veto Caio (and Bruno Malfacine for the same reason) from the World Championship, the IBJJF made a last-minute exception accepting both athletes in. This was the last time someone with less than 1 year experience at brown belt was legally allowed to compete as a black belt in an IBJJF tournament." (from BJJ Heroes- https://www.bjjheroes.com[...]caio-terra)

Belt politics is one of the stupidest parts about BJJ, and keeping in mind that the IBJJF (as much as they are derided for other decisions) are about as close, albeit not in the standard sense of governing bodies, to a sporting authority that we have and it wasn't until 06-07 when they started to tamp down on time in grade regulations/registry.

Of course, I am not trying to defend the IBJJF, however the broader point was the stories from the 90s being recounted, while comedic looking back to them were a relic of their time and indicative of the "wild west" days.

UFC 1 was November of 1993, so even if GM Behring was in Europe in '99, the date from the "premier" of BJJ to the world was just about 5 years old. 5 years doesn't seem like much, but consider the changes to the sport from 2017-2022, today.
Benoit Zenthner
Benoit ZenthnerOP
Black belt 4th degreeVerified518 forum posts12245/1000
4 year(s) ago
This is very interesting, and while it is before my time, I almost sort of understand it. Looking back at the example of Caio Terra/Bruno Malfacine: 'His promotion “landed” on the same year in which the IBJJF set minimum time frames for each belt, making it mandatory for a brown belt to stay in this belt division for a minimum of 1 year before being promoted. As Caio had not hit the time frame outlined by the federation, he was blocked from competing at the 2007 Brazilian Nationals (Brasileiro). Later that year, and although the federation had plans to veto Caio (and Bruno Malfacine for the same reason) from the World Championship, the IBJJF made a last-minute exception accepting both athletes in. This was the last time someone with less than 1 year experience at brown belt was legally allowed to compete as a black belt in an IBJJF tournament.' (from BJJ Heroes- https://www.bjjheroes.com[...]caio-terra) Belt politics is one of the stupidest parts about BJJ, and keeping in mind that the IBJJF (as much as they are derided for other decisions) are about as close, albeit not in the standard sense of governing bodies, to a sporting authority that we have and it wasn't until 06-07 when they started to tamp down on time in grade regulations/registry. Of course, I am not trying to defend the IBJJF, however the broader point was the stories from the 90s being recounted, while comedic looking back to them were a relic of their time and indicative of the 'wild west' days. UFC 1 was November of 1993, so even if GM Behring was in Europe in '99, the date from the 'premier' of BJJ to the world was just about 5 years old. 5 years doesn't seem like much, but consider the changes to the sport from 2017-2022, today.
It's impossible to compare 95-2000 and 2017-2022, imagine that the bjj community in all Europe was like 500 people, with blue belt White and blue belt teachers and when you are Lucky enough to see a purple belt He's like an half-god.... we start the things but now almost each academy got Brown and Black belt, the technical level in general was too low to archive a Black belt in fine years at that time.
Joe Cavett
Joe Cavett
Purple beltVerified434 forum posts4005/400
4 year(s) ago
My general belief is that as martial arts go, BJJ is still relatively young and still growing into itself. I also believe that belt promotions should not have any time in grade requirements and be based on a skill level established in multiple possible ways. If you've got a blue belt consistently destroying black belts, he is not a blue belt and should not be forced to compete as one just because of some arbitrary time hack that they don't meet. As the art grows, it is becoming more and more common to have a 16 year old receiving a blue belt after training for 10-12 years. This 16 year old is physically able to train every day, and likely multiple times per day, and has done so during the period of their life where learning and development are most easily done. Contrast this with the person that started their BJJ journey on the same day as that 16 year old, but was 30 years old at the time. For numerous reasons including age, job, family, and who knows what else they were only able to train 2-4 time per week over that same 10-12 year period and were awarded their black belt on the same day as the 16 year old despite having put in a fraction of the hours on the mats. So speaking purely of grappling ability, which of those is more deserving of a black belt? And yet here we are checking the IBJJF quick reference guide for promotions and determining the 16 year old not worthy even though he is vastly more skilled than most others that have trained for a comparable number of years. This is why masters should have discretion in promotions and not be forced to adhere to some arbitrary time guidelines. It's not the only reason, but it's a good one.
Edited 4 year(s) ago

Post a reply

Add a quote
 
Changes saved
Success
An error occured
Required fields missing
This person is already on Beltchecker.